NorthWestern Energy sells Missoula households two kinds of energy, and this November the two sell heat at very different prices. Per kilowatt-hour, electricity costs about one-fifth what a therm of natural gas costs. A therm holds roughly 29.3 kilowatt-hours of heat, so per unit of heat, electricity is the expensive fuel.
If you're choosing a heating system for a custom home in Canyon River's Phases 9-11, that conversion carries most of the decision. Once you factor in a modern furnace's efficiency and a heat pump's multiplier, the gap shrinks a lot but stays open, and the local rebate programs are built for existing homes, not new construction.
The price of one unit of heat in November 2026
NorthWestern's rate workbook dated November 1, 2026, puts residential electricity at $0.158270 per kilowatt-hour, plus a $4.20 monthly service charge. That makes a 750 kWh month cost $122.90. The same workbook prices residential natural gas at about $0.7811 per therm all-in, plus a $6.50 monthly service charge, so a 65-therm month comes to $57.27. The Montana Public Service Commission's 2026 gas and electric rate summary lists the same $0.15827 electric rate for November.
To compare the fuels fairly, price the heat that ends up in your rooms. The table below does that for 100 therms of delivered heat. It assumes a 95% efficient gas furnace and a heat pump that averages three units of heat for each unit of electricity over a season, plus a colder-weather case where that ratio falls to two. These are round planning assumptions applied to November 2026 rates, and the totals leave out both monthly service charges.
| Heat source, 100 therms delivered | Energy purchased | Approximate cost at November 2026 rates |
|---|---|---|
| Gas furnace, 95% efficient | About 105 therms | About $82 |
| Air-source heat pump, ratio of 3 | About 977 kWh | About $155 |
| Air-source heat pump, ratio of 2 | About 1,465 kWh | About $232 |
| Electric resistance backup | About 2,930 kWh | About $464 |
Even under a generous seasonal assumption, the heat pump's heat costs a little under twice as much as the furnace's.
The number a heat pump has to beat
Divide the resistance cost by the furnace cost and you get the multiplier a heat pump would need to match gas at these prices: about 5.6. A heat pump that turns each kilowatt-hour into 5.6 kilowatt-hours of heat, averaged over a Missoula heating season, would break even with a 95% furnace this November. The table's planning figure of three is well short of that.
The cold makes the gap wider. Electrify Missoula says cold-climate air-source heat pumps can run at 0°F or colder, that running at minus 10°F is possible but generally costs more, and that Montana systems commonly include backup heat. Electric resistance is one of the backup options that page lists, and the bottom row of the table shows what it costs at November rates. The same local group says heat pumps are relatively easy to build into new construction. It also cautions that switching from gas to electricity doesn't always lower bills at current rates.
Missoula's winter multiplies whatever gap you pick
A price gap per unit of heat matters more where a house needs more heat. NOAA's 1991-2020 climate normals for Missoula International Airport show 7,514 heating degree days a year on a 65°F base, 1,246 of them in January alone. Over that same 30-year period, the average January low was 18.0°F, and the airport averaged 6.8 days a year at or below 0°F.
January is where a home's heat load concentrates, so it is the month where any per-unit gap between the fuels adds up fastest. The days near or below zero are the ones the Electrify Missoula caution about colder operation describes.
Going all-electric does save one cost, and it's small. A home without gas service skips the $6.50 monthly gas charge, which is $78 a year at current rates, and pays the $4.20 electric charge either way. In the table's terms, $78 covers about one month's difference on 100 therms of delivered heat.
Local rebate programs are aimed at existing homes
NorthWestern's current E+ rebate forms, effective August 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027, list $450 for a qualifying heat pump and $425 for a high-efficiency gas furnace, and both utility programs are written for existing homes rather than new construction. Locally, Electrify Missoula reports that the City and County's $1,435 rebate for heat pump water heaters was fully allocated as of January 2026, with applications now going to a waitlist. That rebate covered water heating, not space heating.
So for a new Phase 9-11 home, the comparison rests mostly on equipment quotes from your builder and the monthly bills in the table. These figures are general information, not financial advice, so confirm costs for your own build with your builder and the right professionals.
Recent rate moves have been bigger for gas, and still not big enough
Gas prices have risen faster than electricity lately. NorthWestern filed its combined Montana electric and gas rate review in July 2024, and the PSC ruled on November 19, 2025, with the final order following in December. NorthWestern's February 2026 comparison on its rate review page put a typical 65-therm gas bill 10.06% above July 2024 rates and a typical 750 kWh electric bill 5.35% above.
Electric supply prices adjust every quarter. NorthWestern's September 2026 customer notice said the October 1 adjustment would cut a 750 kWh bill by $8.57 a month, or 6.58%, with delivery rates unchanged. Gas supply prices shift monthly, and this fall they barely moved. The PSC summary lists $0.2206 per therm in September, $0.2160 in October and $0.2171 in November, and its 100-therm example bill went from $84.96 to $84.49 to $84.61 over those three months.
Here's how far prices would have to move to close the gap. If electricity holds at its November rate, gas would have to rise about 88% before a heat pump averaging three matched a 95% furnace on cost. Increases of 10% and 5% over roughly a year and a half, plus a quarterly electric cut of under 7%, don't come close. A house built this winter may run for decades, and rates can change a lot over that time. Today's prices give gas a wide lead.
What this means for a Phase 9-11 lot
Start with the lot. Before you price either system, confirm whether gas service reaches the parcel you're considering, because that decides whether you have a choice at all. The Canyon River HOA's developer page sends lot and future-phase questions to Rachael and Stephanie Orizotti, and they can answer it for a specific lot.
Where gas is available, the November 2026 numbers favor gas for the heating load and leave the heat pump an easier case on cooling, which a furnace doesn't provide. Some buyers will want an all-electric home for reasons beyond the monthly bill. That's a reasonable choice, and the table shows roughly what it costs per 100 therms of heat at today's rates. The same numbers explain why lowering the heat load affects your bill as much as the fuel does. Our energy-smart guide for Missoula new builds covers the building envelope, and lot orientation affects how much winter sun you get for free. Whichever system you pick, include it in your custom build budget from the first draft.
FAQ
Does this comparison change after January 1?
NorthWestern's rate page lists January 1, 2027, as the date of the next electric supply and state and local tax adjustment. Rerun the table with the new per-kWh rate and that month's gas price from the PSC summary. To close the gap, prices would have to shift far more than they did in any single adjustment in 2026.
Can a new Phase 9-11 home get a NorthWestern heating rebate?
NorthWestern's current E+ heat pump and gas furnace rebate programs, which run through June 30, 2027, are written for existing homes. Ask your preferred builder which equipment-related programs, if any, fit your build.
Why does the table leave out monthly service charges?
The table compares the cost of the heat itself. The gas service charge is $6.50 a month and the electric charge is $4.20, and an all-electric home pays only the electric one.
If you're choosing a Phase 9-11 lot and want to know which utilities reach it before you draw a single room, Canyon River Properties can answer that for the specific lot and connect you with a preferred builder to price both heating systems against this winter's rates. Start Your Canyon River Story.